Doesn't a composite gasket need to be milled perfectly flat? And not have any warping of the intake as it's running?
I would think that an O-ring would wind up being easier to seal if you had imperfections, or one end not milled as the other.
I haven't ever put my hands on an Offy setup, but judging by the pics, it looks like the only structurally strong piece is the carb mounting bracket, the rest looks like it's built for a little flex?