Howdy All:
Chad- The difference is the bore of the gaskets. 200 & 250 head gaskets come with a 3.75" bore. OTTOMH, the 144 &170 have a bore hole of 3.60". Using a 144 or 170 gasket on a 200/250 would leave a crevasse that may cause sealing problems. Using a 200/250 head gasket on a 144/170 Would have the gasket inside the bore walls, disrupting flow and possibly becoming a hat spot. The one instance I know of were a small head gasket was used on a 200 rebuild was a snow packing machine. It was done several years ago and I haven't heard of how the engine is doing lately.
I am anxious to hear the success of PB's reuse of a OEM shim gasket prepped. OR from anyone reusing a stock steel shim head gasket.
Adios, David