In 1996, the New Zealand Government made some very bad descisions regarding the replacement of hi lead 97 octane gasoline with an aromatic unleaded 96 octane gasoline which had an illegal 56% aromatics hydrocarbon content. It was to be no more than 45%. In the US, the petrochemical company would be sued. Over here, the Government authorised no testing and thus became responsible for absolute mayhem. Engines such as lawn mowers, chainsaws, and some old engines blew up and poor quality carb parts became softened ( SU carb and Weber carb parts espiecially). The benzene content was over 5%, and Cortinas and Austins, already prone to going on fire, stated leaking fuel, and there was a speight of under hood fires.
At this stage, everyone was talking about the disaster, and they couldn't off load there old carby engined clunkers for love nor money. This caused the V8 mob to have severe issues with running the new unleaded 96 octane. Most got VP Plus racing fuel, and spiked it, others used conventional 105 octane avagas, still others decided to run Flash lube, Moreys or ditch there engine for a post 1986 EFI Commodore six or Falcon. It was a disaster.
What I've personally saw at that time was a mate with a stock hi-compression Cortina that had the nasty, detonation prone 9.2:1 compression (Pinto) SOHC 2000 engine that won't run well on high lead 97 ( your 91) octane without detonating. The he added H20 injection, and it ran armoatically inferior 91 octane (your 87) with ease. Saving in 1996 amounted to about 10% per tank of fuel. This happened just by adding water form one source, an original Ford washer bottle, running off an adjustable pressure potentiometer in the manifold. When vacum dropped, the water came in, just like a power valve. Easy.
There was a slight hi rpm performance loss, but no audiable knocking.
At that time, I went to Liquid propane on a car with very high compression (9.7:1 on the rebuilt engine), and since it was 105 octane from the pump, I've never had to run water injection.
I have read every book I can on fuels. I'm comfortable that water injection alone is a power looser, but if the compression is too high, then it is the only option.
When you add a 115 octane alchohol base fuel like methonol, then you gain peformance. If it was good enough for planes in the late 30's and early 40's on the grade of gasoline they had to use then, then I'm all for it.
I've been unduly inflienced by Mr Vizard on this area. He has used it with total sucess. I haven't, but can rationalise why I would. I agree with what SR said, though. Too many systems, too many problems. The best option is to have some discipline, and design your engine around it. On a high pressure turbo, it is a natural.
If I ever run petrol (gasoline) again on any of my engines, it will be a high compression engine and will have water injection at the least.