Here's another method just for grins. First always make sure both mating surfaces are clean & dry, repair any deformation of the valve cover, run masking tape along the inside of the valve cover to form a dam. Plug the bolt holes with pencils or dowels or whatever you have. Now run a bead of silicone (I use the red oil resistant permatex for this application) in the form you've created, wait 15-20 minutes & presto, you created your own gasket.