Howdy Gene and All:
"Quench" is the relationship between the flat, uppermost part of the piston- not the dish, and the flat, head surface- not the oval combustion chamber. When the flat of the piston comes up to the flat surface of the head any A/F mixture lingering there is squeezed out at a high velocity, creating turbulence, which improves combustion. The distance, at the closest point needs to be .040" or less to generate an effective quench effect. Some clearance must be maintained to allow for wear, piston rock and heat expansion.
Our production engines have several strike against them when it comes to maximizing quench effect. 1st is the amount of deck cleanance, which includes the compressed thickness of the head gasket and the deck height of the piston, or how far the top of the pistons are below the deck of the block. With modern, aftermarket composite head gaskets measuring .045" to .055" thick. The other factor- deck height, is typically .025" on a stock 200, much more on a 250
2nd is the miss-match of the oval shape of the stock combustion chamber to the round shape of the dish in the OEM pistons.
3rd would be the fact that most aftermarket pistons, in overbore sizes are typically down on deck height some amount. If you don't know that and deal with it on a rebuild, clearances get bigger.
Ideally, for the highest ratio of quench, you will need a very small chamber in the head, most notably a "Heart-shaped" chamber, and a piston dish to match that shape. You will also need a very clear understanding of the dimensions of all parts to keep a tight quench of between .022" and .034". Is it worth it? Almost all modern engine makers think so. An idealize quench is not only more powerful, but more efficent and economical too.
How to achieve max quench in our engines? Start with a small chamber, pre-'72 head, unshroud and reshape it. Next acquire a set of HSC 2.3 flat-topped pistons and machine a dish into the tops mirroring the shape of the new combustion chambers. Now, how to maximize the rest of the engine????
Thanks for asking the question Gene.
Adios, David