Howdy All:
I have no doubt that your odometer is off enough to not give you an accurate before & after comparison. The one true and easy way to determine your speedo accuracy is a stopwatch and a section of highway with mile markers.
60 seconds is a true 60 mph. Start by timing a measured mile with the speedometer at 60. If the stopwatch is less than 60 seconds, you are traveling at a speed greater than 60 mph, and your odometer will be off a similar %. Given your changes that would be my guess.
If the measured miles times in at say 50 sec. You will be traveling at a true 70 mph- 16.66% difference- and your odometer is off by 16.66% too. Multiply your current mileage readings by 1.1666 and you will have a fairer before-and-after comparison.
Sometimes higher gearing, whether by taller tires or a lower number R & P, causes an engine to lug more, which uses more gas. You might try cruising with a vacuum guage hooked up. As more is being asked of the engine, vacuum and mileage drop.
Check it out.
Adios, David
Too bad you didn't establish some objective baselines before the changes so you would have accurate comparisons.