Supercharger or Turbocharger???

Dan wote
Has it long been known or long been thought that carbs are no good with turbos?
I didn't write that, Dan, and I don't think that one can legitimately conclude from what I did write that I meant that. What I wrote was, It has long been known that pressurised carbs have fuel distribution problems at fairly modest boost levels.

That statement is a mere observation of fact, which is addressed in virtually all books on turbocharging. Here are a few examples, working backwards in time.

In 1997, Corky Bell wrote on page 101 of his book Maximum Boost that "there is little hope for accurate fuel mixture control to satisfy either peak performance or any emission standard." Bell goes on to say that carb'd turbo applications are difficult to make work well above 10 psi boost. Bell's prejudice against carbs is spelled out in clear language in his book, and he makes several outright errors in his comments about carbs, but the comments about mixture control are spot-on.

Hugh McInnes devotes much of Chap 6 in his 1976 book Turbochargers to addressing fuel distribution and mixture control problems.

Finally, way back in 1927 Sir Harry Ricardo devotes quite a bit of The High Speed Internal Combustion Engine's section on turbos to discussing fuel distribution problems.

All of that is NOT to say that carbs and turbos are junk. Quite the opposite. They can be made to work together quite well. It can take considerable effort, though, and the problems of fuel distribution inherent in turbo'd carbs are especially critical for blow-thru setups.
 
Stan, not trying to get anyone upset or anything. Just giving my thoughts on what I have done myself and seen with my own eyes. Like I said I think it is great but that is just me.

Dan
 
I'm not upset, Dan. I just don't want anybody to think that I think turbos and carbs are a junk combination. They do have issues which need to be addressed if the user is going to enjoy the experience, though.
 
xtaxi":2iwgp03p said:
And you don't have to buy electronics and extensive fabrication expertise to make 'em!

True story!!! Plus I am cheap and not very smart so it just makes since! :lol: If I can go fast for cheap that is the way I will almost always go. Just don't ask me why I built a six. :roll:

Dan
 
Back
Top