PCV Valve hook up question.

1. Is this how this car came from the factory?

Not likely but see next answer for the exception.

2. Should I switch from the sealed oil fill cap to a breather cap?

Maybe depends on all the other parts of your PCV system. with any PCV system the engine needs a way to bring air into crankcase. The one exception would be if the valve cover has a separate hose fitting to go to the air cleaner or if the side cover has hose to air cleaner, than you could than use a sealed or closed cap.

3. Should I use an open filter style breather cap?

You can some way the engine needs to breath air into it, but it is not really the best way especially if you are still using a stock type air cleaner than is better to run the hose to it. Though it dose work it allows more dirt into the engine.

4. Should I use a breather cap with a hose that runs into the air cleaner and either modify my air cleaner or find one that already has the setup for a breather cap with a tube?

Can you post a picture of your engine’s air cleaner and PCV hookups it really helps in determining what’s right, or else describe it some more? If the car was suppose to be 100% original it’s starting to sound as if some parts could have been changed.

5. What are the advantages/disadvantages of each system?

Early engines had road draft tubes with an open breather type oil cap. Is the worst of all systems, it worked but allowed lots of dirt into the motor and they would wear out much faster. If you ever had the experience of working on any of these old engines they can be full of enough sludge to fill a quart or gallon container I usually convert the old engines to use a PCV valve.

PC systems can be of open or closed type and were factory installed on some Fords in 1961. The difference between the two is slight an open system uses the filter type breather cap it’s a very good system but it still can allows fine dirt to be drawn into the engine and it will wear out sooner. A closed type system has a breather that is connected to the air cleaner still allows the engine to breath air into the crank case but is also filtered more finely engine stays cleaner inside and last much longer.

6. So what should I do with the PCV system on my 200?

You should make sure you have all the right factory type parts so PCV operates as the factory designed it. I would need to see what you have to know if it has the right parts or not. Are you sure that your oil cap and air cleaner doesn't look like the two pictures in xctasy's post above?
 
EDIT: PCV is primarily an emissions improvement, but believe both open and closed add significant longevity benefits as compared to the early road draft tube crank case ventilation (of the 3 versions used over the main applications of the small six engines) as mentioned .

http://www.aa1car.com/library/pcv.htm

Which type to go with is dependent upon available parts as mentiond...again I'd opt for open or closed vs none (aka road draft) for the sake of less frequent oil/filter changes and engine longevity. Routine quality oil & filter changes, relative to each system, are your best defense against contaminents :wink:

bent8 example, but you get the picture...
http://www.jalopyjournal.com/forum/atta ... 1328068404

Open systems used an 'open' cap with a mesh filter for air inlet, while closed systems used a 'closed' cap with air inlet fed from the breather.

So ultimately the valve cover you go with can dictate your setup. The 'open' pvc valve cover has a small ~2 inch 'stack' for the 'push' on 'open' cap and another opening with a baffle for the pcv and grommet.
While the 'closed' pcv valve cover used a 'twist' on cap with a 'flush' opening keyed to retain the cap and another opening with a baffle for the pcv and grommet.. That cap has a hose connection that should lead back to the air breather.

You can modify an 'open' system's air cleaner to work with the 'closed' system cap by adding a hole on the side or base of the filter as mentioned. However, I would want to be sure to use a 'pcv' inlet element inside the air filter housing first to retain the inlet air hose and secondly (and more importantly) to prevent pressure build up from fouling your air filter element prematurely. Likewise, IIWIYS I would want the pvc element in the filter housing to be located on the outboard side of air filter element. The pcv hose itself, feeding back to the carb, should be located at the lowest position available relative to the carb to maintain correct vacuum on the system and keep the carb cleaner. Good luck :thumbup:
 
Back
Top