Using a drill to spin the pump, has verified that the pressure side of things is probably OK. I would guess the drill spun at a lot less than 750RPM. On a cheaper drill, 200RPM is more likely.
What if the suction side of the pump was drawing air at motor speed (as opposed to "cold cranking" speed)?
What if the suction side of the pump was drawing air at motor speed (as opposed to "cold cranking" speed)?